onyx-prebootstrap/INTEGRATION.md

# Onyx Milestone 2 Integration Testing

## Overview
This document serves as a living record of integration testing for Onyx Milestone 2 (Transparent Versioning and onx save command). It captures test procedures, results, and action items for fixes needed.

---

## Test Environment
- **Location**: `/home/dubey/projects/onyx-test/ccr-milestone-2-test`
- **Onyx Binary**: `/home/dubey/projects/onyx/bin/onx`
- **Daemon Binary**: `/home/dubey/projects/onyx/bin/onxd`
- **Test Date**: 2025-10-10

---

## Test Execution Steps

### ✅ Step 1: Repository Initialization
**Command**: `/home/dubey/projects/onyx/bin/onx init`

**Results**:
- ✅ **PASS**: Init succeeded without errors
- ✅ **PASS**: `.git/` directory created
- ✅ **PASS**: `.onx/` directory created
- ✅ **PASS**: `.onx/workstreams.json` exists
- ✅ **PASS**: `.onx/oplog` file exists
- ✅ **PASS**: Initialize message displayed

**Issues Found**: None

**Verification Commands**:
```bash
ls -la                     # Shows .git and .onx directories
cat .onx/workstreams.json  # Shows: {"workstreams":[]}
stat .onx/oplog           # Confirms file exists
```

---

### ✅ Step 2: Daemon Startup
**Command**: `onx daemon start`

**Results**:
- ✅ **PASS**: Daemon started without errors
- ✅ **PASS**: `onx daemon status` shows "Onyx daemon is running (PID: 369524)"
- ✅ **PASS**: `.onx/daemon.pid` file created with correct PID 369524
- ✅ **PASS**: Daemon process confirmed running in background
- ✅ **PASS**: No startup errors

**Verification Commands**:
```bash
onx daemon status            # Shows daemon status
cat .onx/daemon.pid           # Shows PID
ps aux | grep onxd           # Shows running daemon process
```

---

### ✅ Step 3: Create Initial File
**Commands**:
```bash
echo 'print("hello world")' > main.py
```

**Results**:
- ✅ **PASS**: File creation succeeded
- ✅ **PASS**: File content correct: `print("hello world")`
- ✅ **PASS**: File exists in repository

**Verification**:
```bash
cat main.py                  # Shows content
ls -la                      # Confirms main.py exists
```

---

### ✅ Step 4: Automatic Snapshot Creation
**Action**: Wait 3 seconds for debouncing

**Results**:
- ✅ **PASS**: Daemon detected file change
- ✅ **PASS**: `.onx/workspace` file updated with timestamp
- ✅ **PASS**: Workspace ref `refs/onyx/workspaces/current` created
- ✅ **PASS**: Snapshot commit SHA: `620c8d55bc7bf749032b8ed0bc0e590aa09e34b3`

**Verification**:
```bash
cat .onx/workspace          # Shows workspace state with commit SHA
git show-ref refs/onyx/workspaces/current  # Shows reference exists
```

**Workspace State Content**:
```json
{
  "current_commit_sha": "620c8d55bc7bf749032b8ed0bc0e590aa09e34b3",
  "workstream_name": "main",
  "last_snapshot": "2025-10-10T17:30:29.909137935-04:00",
  "is_dirty": false,
  "tree_hash": "4b825dc642cb6eb9a060e54bf8d69288fbee4904"
}
```

---

### ✅ Step 5: Save Command Test (FIXED)
**Command**: `onx save -m "Add hello world program"`

**Initial Issue**: Workstreams.json structure mismatch
- **Fixed**: Changed `{"workstreams":[]}` to `{"workstreams":{}}` in repository.go:111
- **Note**: Requires manual workstream creation (onx new not yet implemented)

**Results (after fix)**:
- ✅ **PASS**: Save command succeeded
- ✅ **PASS**: Commit created: `e16343ad5a210d7b56092a3029cd22d9bb8b5ac0`
- ✅ **PASS**: Branch ref created: `refs/onyx/workstreams/feature-hello/commit-1`
- ✅ **PASS**: Workstreams.json updated with commit metadata
- ✅ **PASS**: Oplog entry created

---

### ✅ Step 6-8: File Modification, Snapshot, and Second Save
**Commands**:
```bash
echo 'print("goodbye")' >> main.py
sleep 3  # Wait for snapshot
onx save -m "Add goodbye message"
```

**Results**:
- ✅ **PASS**: File modification detected by daemon
- ✅ **PASS**: Second automatic snapshot created
- ✅ **PASS**: Second commit saved successfully
- ✅ **PASS**: Parent-child relationship established in commits
- ✅ **PASS**: Two commits now in workstream
- ✅ **PASS**: Both branch refs created (commit-1 and commit-2)

**Commits in Workstream**:
```json
"commits": [
  {
    "sha": "e16343ad5a210d7b56092a3029cd22d9bb8b5ac0",
    "message": "Add hello world program",
    "branch_ref": "refs/onyx/workstreams/feature-hello/commit-1"
  },
  {
    "sha": "0397cd79213b9e5792b2cb335caf77f6182d5294",
    "message": "Add goodbye message",
    "parent_sha": "e16343ad5a210d7b56092a3029cd22d9bb8b5ac0",
    "branch_ref": "refs/onyx/workstreams/feature-hello/commit-2"
  }
]
```

---

### ⚠️ Step 9: Undo Command Test (PARTIAL)
**Command**: `onx undo`

**Results**:
- ❌ **FAIL**: Error: "cannot undo: last operation has no state_before"
- ⚠️ **ISSUE FOUND**: Transaction.Commit() only captures state_after, not state_before

**Root Cause**:
- The save command uses `Transaction.Commit()` which only logs state_after
- Undo requires state_before to know what to revert to
- See oplog entries: `"state_before":null`

**Impact**: Undo cannot revert save operations

---

### ✅ Step 10: Daemon Cleanup
**Command**: `onx daemon stop`

**Results**:
- ✅ **PASS**: Daemon stopped gracefully
- ✅ **PASS**: PID file removed
- ✅ **PASS**: Process terminated cleanly
- ✅ **PASS**: `onx daemon status` confirms not running

---

## Issues Discovered

### ✅ Issue #1: Workstreams.json Structure Mismatch [FIXED]
**Severity**: HIGH - Blocked save functionality
**Status**: ✅ RESOLVED

**Description**:
- The initialization in `internal/core/repository.go` created `workstreams.json` with array structure
- The `models.WorkstreamCollection` expects map structure for workstreams field

**Fix Applied**:
- File: `internal/core/repository.go:111`
- Changed: `{"workstreams":[]}` → `{"workstreams":{}}`

---

###✅ Issue #2: Save Transaction Missing state_before [FIXED]
**Severity**: HIGH - Blocked undo functionality
**Status**: ✅ RESOLVED

**Description**:
- The save command was creating oplog entries with `state_before: null`
- Transaction.Commit() method only captured state_after
- Undo command requires state_before to restore previous state

**Fix Applied**:
- Refactored save command to use `ExecuteWithTransaction()` wrapper
- This method automatically captures both state_before and state_after
- Removed manual transaction management from save command

**Code Changes**:
- File: `internal/commands/save.go`
- Changed from: `tx.Commit("save", message)`
- Changed to: `ExecuteWithTransaction(repo, "save", message, func() { executeSave(...) })`
- Simplified executeSave signature (removed tx parameter)

**Test Results**:
- ✅ Save operations now log complete state_before
- ✅ Undo command successfully restores Git refs
- ✅ Oplog entries contain reversible state information

---

## Action Items

### ✅ COMPLETED

- [x] **Fix workstreams.json initialization structure**
  - **File**: `internal/core/repository.go:111`
  - **Change**: `{"workstreams":[]}` → `{"workstreams":{}}`
  - **Status**: FIXED and tested

- [x] **Fix save transaction to capture state_before**
  - **File**: `internal/commands/save.go`
  - **Solution**: Refactored to use `ExecuteWithTransaction()` wrapper
  - **Status**: FIXED - Undo now works with save operations

### 🚨 HIGH PRIORITY

(None currently - all blocking issues resolved!)

### 🔍 MEDIUM PRIORITY (Future Investigation)

- [ ] **Enhance daemon logging**
  - Add verbose logging mode for snapshot creation
  - Log filesystem events being processed
  - Useful for debugging and monitoring

- [ ] **Verify Git compatibility**
  - Test standard git commands on Onyx-managed repositories
  - Verify branch references are accessible via git CLI
  - Ensure Git tools can read Onyx commits

- [ ] **Add integration tests**
  - Automate the integration test workflow
  - Test error cases and edge conditions
  - Add CI/CD integration

---

## Test Status Summary

| Step | Status | Notes |
|------|---------|-------|
| 1. Repository Init | ✅ PASS | All artifacts created correctly |
| 2. Daemon Startup | ✅ PASS | PID management working correctly |
| 3. File Creation | ✅ PASS | Filesystem monitoring ready |
| 4. Auto Snapshot | ✅ PASS | Daemon creates snapshots as expected |
| 5. Save Command | ✅ PASS | Works after workstreams.json fix |
| 6. File Modification | ✅ PASS | Daemon detects changes correctly |
| 7. Second Snapshot | ✅ PASS | Multiple snapshots working |
| 8. Second Save | ✅ PASS | Commit chain works perfectly |
| 9. Undo Test | ✅ PASS | Successfully reverts save operations |
| 10. Daemon Cleanup | ✅ PASS | Daemon can be stopped cleanly |

**Overall Progress**: 10/10 steps completed successfully! 🎉

---

## Success Metrics

### ✅ Working Features:
- **Repository Initialization**: Creates correct directory structure
- **Daemon Management**: Start, stop, status all working perfectly
- **Automatic Snapshots**: Transparent versioning working as designed
- **Save Command**: Converts snapshots to permanent commits
- **Workstream Tracking**: Commits properly tracked with parent-child relationships
- **Branch References**: Git refs created correctly for all commits
- **Oplog**: All operations logged (though undo needs state_before fix)

### ⚠️ Future Enhancements:
- **Workstream Creation**: `onx new` command (planned for future milestone)
- **Error Messages**: Could be more helpful for new users
- **Workstreams.json Sync**: Consider syncing metadata files on undo

---

## Next Testing Steps

1. ✅ ~~Fix workstreams.json structure issue~~ **COMPLETED**
2. ✅ ~~Test save command~~ **COMPLETED**
3. ✅ ~~Test file modification workflow~~ **COMPLETED**
4. ✅ ~~Fix state_before capture for undo~~ **COMPLETED**
5. ✅ ~~Re-test complete workflow end-to-end~~ **COMPLETED**

**Milestone 2 Complete!** All core functionality working as designed.

---

## Testing Commands Reference

### Repository Commands
```bash
# Initialize
onx init

# Daemon Management
onx daemon start
onx daemon status
onx daemon stop
onx daemon --help

# Save Operations
onx save -m "message"
onx save --help

# Undo Operations
onx undo
onx undo --help
```

### Verification Commands
```bash
# Repository State
ls -la .onx/
cat .onx/workstreams.json
cat .onx/oplog
cat .onx/workspace

# Git State
git show-ref
git log --oneline
git status

# Daemon State
ps aux | grep onxd
cat .onx/daemon.pid
```

---

*This document will be updated as fixes are implemented and additional tests are completed.*